The weekly Executive Briefing: insights, books, tools, and media opportunities worth your attention — curated and distilled into 5 minutes.
Someone in your leadership meeting has just said you need the right people on the bus, and you would like the whole book before the next one. Here is the Good to Great summary: seven ideas, drawn from 11 companies whose shares beat the market at least three times over for 15 years.
Jim Collins’ Good to Great came out on 16 October 2001, so its companies have had 25 years to bear the book out or spoil it. We read their filings and releases to see where each one stands.
If you are deciding whether it earns a full read, our How to Read a Book summary covers Mortimer Adler’s rule of inspecting a book before you commit to it. Our check of The Psychology of Money found eight of 16 factual claims matched their sources.
What We Found
Of the 11 companies Jim Collins named in Good to Great in 2001, seven were still independent and exchange-listed on 15 November 2026, two had been acquired, one was liquidated and one is in government conservatorship.
The seven are Abbott, Kimberly-Clark, Kroger, Nucor, Pitney Bowes, Wells Fargo and Philip Morris, renamed Altria in 2003. Procter & Gamble bought Gillette in 2005, and Sycamore Partners took Walgreens’ parent company private in 2025. Circuit City went into liquidation in 2009. Fannie Mae has been in federal conservatorship since 6 September 2008.
Two of the 11 turned to the US Treasury in 2008. Fannie Mae is still backed by a Treasury stock purchase agreement, and Wells Fargo issued $25 billion of preferred stock to the Treasury that October. Collins used both as worked examples in his October 2001 Fast Company article.
Good to Great Summary: The 7 Ideas in Order
Collins says on his own site that the research took five years, with 21 research associates at his management laboratory in Boulder, Colorado. In that article he describes screening 1,435 established companies and finding 11 whose returns averaged 6.9 times the market’s.
The Good to Great book runs to 320 pages and nine chapters. The publisher’s synopsis gives the first to the project’s scope, the next seven to the ideas and the last to his earlier book, Built to Last. This Good to Great summary takes the seven in order.
1. Level 5 Leadership. The chief executives behind all 11 turnarounds paired personal humility with fierce will.
2. First Who, Then What. Get the right people in and the wrong people out before you choose a direction.
3. Confront the Brutal Facts. Face the worst facts of your position while keeping faith that you will come through, a pairing Collins calls the Stockdale Paradox.
4. The Hedgehog Concept. Find the one thing you can be best at, that pays, and that your people care about.
5. A Culture of Discipline. Self-disciplined people need fewer rules. Bureaucracy grows to make up for the few wrong hires.
6. Technology Accelerators. Technology adds speed to a change already under way. Collins held in 2001 that it earns its place only once change has begun.
7. The Flywheel and the Doom Loop. Results build like a heavy wheel pushed one way for years. Companies that keep changing direction fall into the doom loop.
What Is Level 5 Leadership?
Level 5 leadership is Jim Collins’ name, in Good to Great, for the kind of chief executive he found at all 11 companies: a person who combines personal humility with fierce resolve and aims their ambition at the organisation instead of themselves. Level 5 leaders are often quiet and reserved, and they lead through high standards more than charisma.
It is the hardest of the seven to act on, because Collins’ page on it describes a person more than a practice. The wider research is less kind to quiet leaders: the 2002 review behind our guide to leadership theories found extraversion had the strongest link to being seen as a leader and to being effective.
The usable part is asking where your ambition points. Marcus Aurelius kept twelve books of private notes on doing the work in front of him without vanity, and our Meditations summary traces 13 of the 20 most-liked quotes on Goodreads to his text.

What Does First Who, Then What Mean?
First Who, Then What means choosing the team before choosing the direction. In Good to Great, Jim Collins reports that the leaders of the 11 companies first got the right people in, moved the wrong people out and filled the key seats, and only then decided where to take the business. A strong team, he argues, adapts when plans change.
Who Are the Right People on the Bus?
On Collins’ page for the idea, the right people on the bus are those who joined for the team more than the destination, who need little managing, and who can change course when the route does. He puts it bluntly: “Great vision without great people is irrelevant.”
His worked example is Fannie Mae. When David Maxwell became chief executive in 1981, Collins writes, the company was losing $1 million every business day. Fourteen of 26 executives left, and it ended up earning $4 million a day.
For a small firm the idea is costly to apply. Our piece on hiring your first employee uses Bureau of Labor Statistics figures to put the cost of a hire at roughly a third more than the salary.
What Is the Stockdale Paradox?
The Stockdale Paradox is the discipline of holding two things at once: complete faith that you will come through in the end, and a clear view of the worst facts of your present situation. Jim Collins named it in Good to Great after Admiral Jim Stockdale, who was held for eight years as a prisoner of war in Vietnam.
Collins’ account says Stockdale was the highest-ranking US officer in the Hanoi Hilton camp, held from 1965 to 1973 and tortured more than twenty times. Asked who did not make it out, he named the optimists, the men who expected to be home by Christmas, then by Easter.
Collins’ management example, on the companion page, is Winston Churchill, who set up a Statistical Office outside the chain of command so that unfiltered facts kept reaching him. Viktor Frankl drew a related lesson from the Nazi camps, and our Man’s Search for Meaning summary traces 17 of his 21 most quoted lines to the book.
What Is the Hedgehog Concept?
The Hedgehog Concept is a simple, clear understanding of what a company should focus on, found where three circles overlap: what its people care deeply about, what it can be best in the world at, and what drives its economic engine. In Good to Great, Jim Collins separates that understanding from a mere goal to be best.
The name comes from Isaiah Berlin’s essay The Hedgehog and the Fox, in which the fox knows many things and the hedgehog one big thing, Collins’ page says. His example is Wells Fargo, which dropped most of its international business, set out to “run a bank like a business” in the western United States, and changed its measure from profit per loan to profit per employee.
The third circle asks what makes money, a different question from what sells. Our timeline of Jessica Alba and the Honest Company shows revenue up 58 percent from 2019 to 2025 with a net loss in all seven years. The engine can also sit somewhere unexpected. Forbes puts Magic Johnson’s net worth at $1.6 billion, against about $40 million in Lakers salary.
A measure that sharp needs watching. In 2016 the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau fined Wells Fargo $100 million after employees opened more than two million accounts that customers may not have authorised, to hit sales targets and earn bonuses.
What Is a Culture of Discipline?
A culture of discipline, in Good to Great, means self-disciplined people who think rigorously and then act inside a clear framework of responsibilities. Jim Collins’ page on it sets the order as disciplined people, disciplined thought, then disciplined action, and argues that bureaucracy grows mainly to compensate for the few wrong people a company has hired.
The working move is to decide what to stop. Collins’ example is Darwin Smith of Kimberly-Clark, who sold the company’s paper mills to concentrate on consumer products. Benjamin Franklin ran a personal version, a weekly chart of 13 virtues, and admitted in print that he never kept to it. Our piece on Benjamin Franklin’s 13 virtues found half of the 20 pages we read printing the list leave the admission out.
What Is the Flywheel Effect?
The flywheel effect is Jim Collins’ image, in Good to Great, for how lasting results are built: like pushing a heavy flywheel in one direction, one turn after another, until momentum takes over. No single action, programme or lucky break produces the breakthrough. Its opposite is the doom loop, where a company keeps changing direction and never builds momentum.
His example is Walgreens, which tracked the market for more than 40 years and began to climb in 1975. “There was no miracle moment,” Collins writes.
The flywheel concept is the easiest of the seven to see outside business. Our check of the Hugh Jackman workout found that, in his own words, it comes down to heavy basic lifts, a rowing machine and a six-month run-up to his last Wolverine film.

What Happened to the 11 Good to Great Companies?
Seven of the 11 Good to Great companies were still independent and listed on a US stock exchange on 15 November 2026: Abbott, Kimberly-Clark, Kroger, Nucor, Pitney Bowes, Wells Fargo and Altria, the renamed Philip Morris. Gillette and Walgreens were acquired, Circuit City was liquidated in 2009, and Fannie Mae has been in government conservatorship since 2008.
The table gives the transition year Collins used for each company, taken from a glossary entry that cites the book, what has happened since publication, and where the company stood when we checked.
| Company | Transition year | What happened after 2001 | Status on 15 November 2026 | Sources |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Abbott Laboratories | 1974 | Spun off its research-based drugs business as AbbVie on 1 January 2013. Completed the purchase of Exact Sciences on 23 March 2026. | Independent. Common shares listed on the New York Stock Exchange as ABT. | Abbott release, 2 January 2013; results release, 21 October 2026; Form 8-K cover |
| Circuit City | 1982 | Filed for Chapter 11 in November 2008. Announced on 16 January 2009 that it would liquidate, with 567 US stores. Its last stores closed in 2009 after 60 years in business. | Liquidated. | Circuit City release, 16 January 2009; NPR, 2009 |
| Fannie Mae | 1984 | Placed in conservatorship under the Federal Housing Finance Agency on 6 September 2008. | Still in conservatorship. Shares trade over the counter as FNMA. Net worth of $119.6 billion at 30 September 2026. | FHFA; results release, 28 October 2026 |
| Gillette | 1980 | Acquired by Procter & Gamble on 1 October 2005 for about $53.5 billion. | A Procter & Gamble grooming brand. No separate listing. | P&G Form 10-Q, quarter to 31 December 2005; P&G brands page |
| Kimberly-Clark | 1972 | Stayed independent. Completed its purchase of Kenvue on 2 November 2026. | Independent. Nasdaq: KMB. | Results release, 5 November 2026 |
| Kroger | 1973 | Stayed independent. | Independent. NYSE: KR. Second-quarter 2026 sales of $34.6 billion. | Results release, 11 September 2026 |
| Nucor | 1975 | Stayed independent. | Independent. NYSE: NUE. Third-quarter 2026 net sales of $11.25 billion. | Results release, 26 October 2026 |
| Philip Morris | 1964 | Renamed Altria Group in 2003. Spun off Kraft Foods in 2007 and Philip Morris International in 2008. | Independent as Altria. NYSE: MO. Philip Morris USA is a wholly owned subsidiary. | Altria history page; results release, 29 October 2026 |
| Pitney Bowes | 1973 | Stayed independent. | Independent. NYSE: PBI. Third-quarter 2026 revenue of $456 million. | Results release, 28 October 2026 |
| Walgreens | 1975 | Sycamore Partners completed its purchase of Walgreens Boots Alliance on 28 August 2025 for $11.45 a share in cash, plus a right to as much as $3.00 more. | Privately owned. Shares no longer listed on Nasdaq. | Sycamore Partners release, 28 August 2025 |
| Wells Fargo | 1983 | Issued $25 billion of preferred stock to the US Treasury in October 2008 and said on 14 December 2009 it would redeem all of it. Fined $100 million by the CFPB in 2016. A Federal Reserve cap on its growth, set in 2018, was lifted on 3 June 2025. | Independent. NYSE: WFC. About $2.3 trillion in assets. | Wells Fargo release, 14 December 2009; CFPB, 8 September 2016; Federal Reserve, 3 June 2025; results release, 13 October 2026 |
The economist Steven Levitt ran the investor’s test in July 2008. By his reckoning a portfolio of the 11 would have underperformed the S&P 500, and only Nucor had dramatically beaten the market since the book came out.
A company list printed in 2001 goes stale the way any published figure does. Our count of Rihanna net worth pages found nine of the 30 crediting Forbes still showing $1.7 billion, against the $1 billion Forbes displays now.
What 25 Years Do to the Book’s Claim
Collins did not promise the 11 would stay great. His test was a 15-year run from each transition year, and the last of those runs, Fannie Mae’s from 1984, ended before the book was printed. In a 2009 article on his own site, after Circuit City and Fannie Mae had fallen, he argued that a later fall “doesn’t invalidate what we can learn by studying that company” at its best.
On those terms the 25-year record leaves the book standing. It does take away the comfortable reading, that these habits protect a company. Fannie Mae, his model for choosing people first, and Wells Fargo, his model for the hedgehog, both drew on the Treasury seven years after publication.
The method has a limit too. Collins did compare the 11 with companies that did not make the leap. Still, the 11 were chosen because their shares had already risen, and Levitt called such books “mostly backward-looking”. Napoleon Hill also built his steps on men who had already made it, and our Think and Grow Rich summary found that 29 of the 42 men in his preface we could date had died before it was published.
Evidence ages too. Our Thinking, Fast and Slow summary found four of 16 headline studies held up when retested and five failed.
What holds up is what you can test. Picking people before plans, hearing bad numbers unsoftened, naming one economic measure and pushing one way for years all cost little to try. Give each a trial with an end date. Novak Djokovic gave up gluten for fourteen days before deciding, and our check of the Djokovic diet traced 18 of 24 famous claims to his own words.
How We Did This
On 15 November 2026 our newsroom took the 11 companies Jim Collins names as good-to-great and traced what has happened to each since the book came out in October 2001. We fetched a securities filing, a regulator’s page or a company page or release for every one, 19 pages in all, plus one NPR report. A company counts as independent if it reports its own results and its shares are listed on the New York Stock Exchange or Nasdaq.
For the seven independent companies, status comes from the latest results release we could load, dated between 11 September and 5 November 2026. Events before publication were not counted, and we did not measure share-price returns. The transition years come from a glossary entry citing the book. The Good to Great summary above draws on Collins’ own site and his October 2001 Fast Company article, which we read again on 16 November. The full dataset, with the quote and source for every row, is available on request.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Good to Great still relevant?
The management habits are. Choosing people first, facing bad news early and building momentum over years cost little to test on any team. The company list has aged. Seven of the 11 are still independent, and four have been bought, liquidated or placed in conservatorship.
What are the main concepts of Good to Great?
There are seven: Level 5 Leadership, First Who Then What, Confront the Brutal Facts with its Stockdale Paradox, the Hedgehog Concept, a Culture of Discipline, Technology Accelerators, and the Flywheel and the Doom Loop. Any Good to Great book summary should carry all seven.
Which Good to Great companies failed?
Circuit City is the only one that was liquidated, after filing for Chapter 11 in November 2008. Fannie Mae was placed in government conservatorship in September 2008 and is still there. Gillette and Walgreens were bought, for shares and for cash, which gave their shareholders an exit.
Collins studied 15 good years at each of the 11, and the 25 years since have added two takeovers, a liquidation and a conservatorship. Take the seven ideas as habits to try on your own team, and judge them by your own numbers.

Written by
Editor of The Executive Insight. Writes about leadership, decision-making and the parts of building a business that nobody puts in the plan.
Explore other articles
-
business strategy
Hiring your first employee is the point at which a self-employed person becomes an employer, and almost everyone gets the arithmetic wrong in the same direction. They budget the salary, confirm the revenue covers it, and make the offer. The salary is not the cost. It is somewhere between two thirds and three quarters of […]
7 min read -
business strategy
Forty million dollars in salary, $1.6 billion in the bank. Forbes put Magic Johnson net worth at $1.6 billion when we checked on 15 November 2026, and Celebrity Net Worth gave the same figure. His whole Lakers salary comes to about 2.5 percent of that. The rest was built after he stopped playing, most of […]
17 min read -
business strategy
Search the number and you get more than one answer. Forbes put Mark Cuban net worth at $6.8 billion when we checked on 14 November 2026, in a figure dated 10 November. Celebrity Net Worth said $6.5 billion. Most pages that quote Forbes still print an older number, and Bloomberg has run more than $2 […]
17 min read









