You read the briefing pack twice, it felt familiar, and in the meeting the numbers would not come. Here is the make it stick summary. Rereading builds a feeling of knowing. Recalling from memory, spacing your practice and mixing topics build knowledge that lasts, even though they feel slower and harder while you do them.

The book is Make It Stick: The Science of Successful Learning, published in 2014 by Harvard University Press. Peter C. Brown, a writer and novelist, wrote it with Henry L. Roediger III and Mark A. McDaniel, psychologists at Washington University in St. Louis. Below are its five techniques and its chapters, and then a check. We took 13 of the studies its endnotes cite and traced each one to the paper itself: the journal, the year, the sample and what the authors found.

What We Found

Of 13 studies cited in Make It Stick, traced to their papers on 20 November 2026, all seven pitting a harder method against an easier one found the harder one won; in three, the easier looked better at first.

The seven cover testing against rereading, spaced against massed study, mixed against blocked practice, and producing an answer against reading it. In Doug Rohrer and Kelli Taylor’s maths study, the harder method won by 63 percent to 20 percent a week later.

As for the three where the easy route led early, rereaders beat testers on a test five minutes later. Students practising maths in blocks scored higher during practice. And 78 percent of people in a study of painters’ styles rated blocked study as good as mixing or better, though mixing scored higher.

Many samples are small. Three of the seven head-to-head studies used 30 people or fewer. We have run the same check on two other books about getting better at things. Our Carol Dweck mindset summary set a 59-point gap among 128 children in 1998 against a correlation of .10 across 365,915 students. Our summary of Angela Duckworth’s Grit found a 2017 meta-analysis of 66,807 people putting grit’s overlap with conscientiousness at .84.

What Is the Make It Stick Book About?

The Make It Stick book argues that most people study in the ways that feel productive and work worst. Rereading and cramming produce a familiarity that fades. The alternative it offers takes more effort: test yourself, space the sessions, mix the topics, vary the conditions, and try to produce an answer before you are shown it.

Summaries tend to drop the evidence, the half that tells you how far to trust the advice. Of 16 free summaries of The Power of Now we read, only seven mentioned the clock-time carve-out that makes Eckhart Tolle usable at a desk. Here the missing half is the endnotes, posted as a PDF at makeitstick.com.

Make It Stick: The Science of Successful Learning, Chapter by Chapter

Make It Stick: The Science of Successful Learning has eight chapters. The first says learning is misunderstood. The next three cover retrieval, mixed practice and useful difficulty. The last four deal with illusions of knowing, learning styles, raising your abilities and a closing chapter that shares the book’s title. Open Library’s record lists 336 pages.

The endnotes show where the evidence sits. Chapter one cites the rereading research and a survey of how students study. Chapter three, Mix Up Your Practice, holds the notes on spacing, interleaving and varied practice. Chapter four, Embrace Difficulties, cites the generation effect and a batting study with junior college baseball players.

Make It Stick Summary: 13 Studies Traced to the Papers

This make it stick summary rests on the table below. Each row is a study the book’s endnotes cite, with the journal and sample as the paper reports them. The five techniques are retrieval practice, spacing, interleaving, varied practice and generation; the last three rows cover habits and ideas the book warns against.

Study Technique Journal Sample What the paper found Harder method won?
Roediger and Karpicke, 2006 Retrieval practice Psychological Science 120 students (experiment 1) Tested group recalled 56% a week later, rereaders 42%; rereaders led at five minutes, 81% to 75% Yes
Karpicke, Butler and Roediger, 2009 Retrieval practice (survey) Memory 177 students 84% listed rereading; 11% said they practised retrieval; 2 of 177 ranked it first Not a comparison
Karpicke, 2009 Retrieval practice (choices) Journal of Experimental Psychology: General 42 students (experiment 2) Learners dropped 60% of word pairs after recalling them; their confidence ran ahead of later recall Not a comparison
Larsen, Butler and Roediger, 2009 Retrieval practice Medical Education 40 residents Testing 39%, studying 26%, about six months later Yes
McDaniel and colleagues, 2011 Retrieval practice Journal of Educational Psychology Eighth-grade science classes; size not on the page we loaded Quizzing gave 13% to 25% gains; benefits lasted to semester and end-of-year exams Not a comparison
Cepeda and colleagues, 2006 Spacing Psychological Bulletin Review of 317 experiments in 184 articles Spaced study consistently beat massed study, whatever the delay Yes
Rohrer and Taylor, 2007 Interleaving Instructional Science 18 students (experiment 2) Mixed practice 63% a week later, blocked 20%; blocked led during practice, 89% to 60% Yes
Kornell and Bjork, 2008 Interleaving Psychological Science 120 people (experiment 1a) Mixed study .61 correct, blocked .35; 78% judged blocking as good or better Yes
Hall, Domingues and Cavazos, 1994 Varied practice Perceptual and Motor Skills 30 junior college baseball players Hitting improved 56.7% with random pitches, 24.8% with blocked, 6.2% for controls Yes
Slamecka and Graf, 1978 Generation Journal of Experimental Psychology: Human Learning and Memory 24 students (experiment 1) Generated words beat read words in all five experiments Yes
Callender and McDaniel, 2009 Rereading Contemporary Educational Psychology Four experiments; size not on the page we loaded A second reading rarely raised scores over a single reading Not a comparison
Kruger and Dunning, 1999 Illusions of knowing Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 65 students (study 1) Bottom-quarter scorers placed themselves at the 62nd percentile; they scored at the 12th Not a comparison
Pashler, McDaniel, Rohrer and Bjork, 2008 Learning styles Psychological Science in the Public Interest Literature review Virtually no evidence for matching teaching to a preferred style Not a comparison

Seven of the 13 are head-to-head comparisons, and the harder method won all seven. The other six describe habits, judgments and claims. Six of the 13 carry Roediger’s or McDaniel’s name, which is natural in a book they co-wrote.

Small samples are common among classics. Jim Collins built Good to Great on 11 companies, and when we checked what 25 years did to those 11 companies, seven were still independent and listed. A small study can point the right way. What it cannot pin down is the size of the effect.

Going back to the paper matters because retellings drift. Of 21 stories in The Obstacle Is the Way we checked against the record, 12 match. Of 27 repeated claims about the Chris Hemsworth diet, five rest on nobody. Even the book’s notes slip. They date the same Karpicke, Butler and Roediger survey 2010 in chapter one and 2009 in chapter two. Memory published it in 2009.

A senior physician quizzing a resident in a hospital atrium, the retrieval practice Make It Stick recommends

What Is Retrieval Practice?

Retrieval practice means pulling information out of memory, by quizzing yourself or recalling from a blank page, in place of putting it back in by rereading. In Make It Stick it is the lead technique. Roediger and Karpicke’s 2006 study found that students who were tested recalled 56 percent of a passage a week later, against 42 percent for rereaders.

In that study of 120 Washington University undergraduates, the rereaders did better five minutes later, 81 percent to 75 percent. At two days and at a week, the order flipped. In a second experiment, students who had only restudied were the most confident they would remember.

The effect holds outside the laboratory. In a 2009 randomised trial by Douglas Larsen, Andrew Butler and Roediger, 40 residents were each tested repeatedly on one neurological condition and given a review sheet to study on another. About six months later they scored 39 percent on the tested topic and 26 percent on the studied one.

Two Science papers led by Jeffrey Karpicke, which the book’s notes do not cite, go further. In 2008, students who kept retrieving 40 Swahili word pairs recalled about 80 percent a week later, against 36 percent or less when items were dropped from testing. With Janell Blunt in 2011, retrieval beat concept mapping on a test a week later, 0.67 to 0.45.

The cheapest version needs only a blank page. After a briefing, write down what you remember before you look again. Our piece on the Feynman technique found 14 of 16 guides giving four steps, and argued that the test that counts is rebuilding the idea yourself without notes. Our guide on how to learn faster turns this into six moves for a new role.

What Is Spaced Repetition?

Spaced repetition means coming back to material after gaps, letting some forgetting happen between sessions, in place of massing the practice together. Make It Stick treats spacing as a core technique. A 2006 review by Nicholas Cepeda and colleagues pooled 839 assessments from 317 experiments and found spaced study consistently beat massed study, whatever the delay before the test.

The review also found that the best gap grows with the time until the test. A 2008 follow-up by the same group, with more than 1,350 people, put it at about 20 percent of the delay for a test a few weeks away and about 5 percent for one a year out.

What Is Interleaving?

Interleaving means mixing different kinds of problem or skill in one practice session in place of finishing one kind before starting the next. In Make It Stick, interleaving is the hardest technique to trust. In Rohrer and Taylor’s 2007 study, students who practised mixed maths problems scored 63 percent a week later; blocked practice scored 20 percent.

During practice, the blocked group looked far better, 89 percent to 60 percent. Anyone judging by the practice session would have picked the method that lost.

Nate Kornell and Robert Bjork found the same trap with art. In their 2008 study, 120 people learned the styles of 12 painters, either one artist at a time or mixed. Mixing produced .61 correct against .35 for blocking, yet 78 percent said blocking was as good as or better than mixing.

Sport shows it as well. Kellie Green Hall and colleagues gave 30 junior college baseball players 12 extra batting sessions. On a test with mixed pitches, players who had faced fastballs, curveballs and change-ups in random order improved their hitting by 56.7 percent; those who had faced them in blocks of 15 improved by 24.8 percent.

Coaching methods drift in the retelling too. Of 15 ideas the pages we read attach to Nick Saban’s Process, ten trace to Saban’s own words and four to someone else.

A redbrick baseball park in midday sun, the kind of setting for the batting practice study cited in Make It Stick

What Are Desirable Difficulties?

Desirable difficulties are kinds of effort that make learning slower at the time and stronger later. The term comes from the psychologist Robert Bjork, and Make It Stick builds its fourth chapter around it. In a 2011 overview that credits the term to his 1994 work, Elizabeth and Robert Bjork list four: varying the conditions of learning, interleaving topics, spacing sessions, and using tests in place of presentations.

Generation is the oldest example in the book’s notes. In 1978 Slamecka and Graf compared words that people produced themselves from a cue with words they simply read. Across five experiments, the generated words were remembered better every time.

Rereading is the easy option the book argues against. In four experiments by Aimee Callender and McDaniel, a second reading rarely raised scores over a single one. In 2013 John Dunlosky and four colleagues rated ten study techniques, and the Association for Psychological Science reported practice testing and distributed practice rated highest, rereading and highlighting among five rated low.

Why Learners Pick the Method That Loses

The book’s fifth chapter is about the gap between feeling ready and being ready. A 2009 survey by Karpicke, Butler and Roediger asked 177 college students how they studied. Rereading was the most listed strategy, named by 84 percent and ranked first by 55 percent. Only 11 percent said they practised retrieval while studying, and two of the 177 put it first.

Justin Kruger and David Dunning measured the same gap in skill. Across four studies published in 1999, people who scored in the bottom quarter estimated they were at the 62nd percentile. Their scores put them at the 12th.

The fix is to test the feeling against something outside your head, such as a quiz or a colleague’s question. We apply the same rule to famous claims. Of 37 facts about Tobey Maguire’s poker game, 14 rest on court or government records. Of 13 deals behind Jay-Z’s net worth, three carry a price published by a party to the deal. A claim heard often feels checked, which is the illusion of knowing applied to other people.

What the Book Says About Learning Styles

Chapter six takes on learning styles, the idea that people learn best when teaching matches a preferred mode, such as visual or auditory. Its notes cite a review by Harold Pashler, McDaniel, Doug Rohrer and Robert Bjork, which found virtually no evidence for that matching and concluded there was no adequate evidence base for learning-styles assessments in general teaching.

How to Use Make It Stick at Work

If you reread a board pack, close it after the first read, write down the five numbers that matter, then check. If you are learning a new market, quiz yourself the next day and again a week later. When you practise anything with several kinds of case, mix them.

For teams, swap the end-of-training recap for a short quiz a week later. Written culture drifts too: of 37 ideas we logged from the 2009 Netflix culture deck, our check found 19 intact in the current memo.

Every technique here is free. Of the 53 steps in the Bryan Johnson Blueprint, 14 name nothing to buy, and retrieval, spacing and interleaving belong in that column. Spacing needs a calendar more than willpower, and even a famous calendar is hard to pin down: our trace of Winston Churchill’s daily routine found 61 accounts, 40 of them first-hand.

Any make it stick summary ends on the same warning. The method that feels better in the session often loses a week later, so judge a technique by the delayed test.

How We Did This

For this make it stick summary, on 20 November 2026 our newsroom took the book’s endnotes, from the PDF at makeitstick.com, and picked the studies behind each technique it recommends and each habit it warns against. We tried to trace 14 to the original paper and loaded 13, as a full-text copy or as an abstract or record on a publisher, university or index page.

For each we recorded the journal, year, sample as the paper states it and main finding, with a supporting line. A study counts as head to head when it compared a harder method with an easier one on the same material, and as a win when the harder method scored better on the final test.

Kerr and Booth’s 1978 beanbag study was dropped because no copy loaded. Karpicke’s 2008 and 2011 Science papers are left out of the count because the endnotes do not cite them. The full dataset, with sources and supporting text for every row, is available on request.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the testing effect?

The testing effect is the finding that taking a test on material improves later memory of it more than spending the same time restudying. In Roediger and Karpicke’s 2006 study, tested students recalled 56 percent of a passage after a week and rereaders 42 percent, though rereaders did better five minutes after studying.

What is the illusion of knowing?

The illusion of knowing is the sense that you have learned something because it feels familiar, and rereading produces it easily. Make It Stick gives it a chapter. In Kornell and Bjork’s study, 78 percent of learners rated blocked study as good as or better than mixing, though mixing produced the higher scores.

Is Make It Stick worth reading?

Yes, if you train people or have to learn fast. The seven head-to-head comparisons we traced among its sources all went the book’s way. Several samples are small, so treat the exact percentages as rough and the direction as solid.

In Roediger and Karpicke’s study, rereading won the test five minutes later and lost the one a week later, and the students who had only reread were the surest they would remember.

Latest From The Executive Insight