The weekly Executive Briefing: insights, books, tools, and media opportunities worth your attention — curated and distilled into 5 minutes.
You help a colleague for the third time this week and your own deadline slips again. The Adam Grant Give and Take argument speaks to that moment. People at work act as givers, takers or matchers, and givers finish at the bottom of the ladder and at the top. Grant’s answer is to keep giving and change how.
The book rests on research, so our newsroom went to the research. We took 15 studies from the book’s reference list, found each one at its source, and wrote down who was studied, how many of them, and what the paper itself reports.
What We Found
Of the 15 studies behind Give and Take we traced to their sources, three carry the claim that givers finish at the top and the bottom, and one is a 2011 working paper we could not find published.
We checked on 14 November 2026. Fourteen of the 15 ran in peer-reviewed journals. The exception is the sales study, listed in the book’s own references as a working paper by Grant and Dane Barnes. It is the source of the book’s 50 percent revenue figure for giver salespeople.
Two more things stood out. The medical school paper reports a positive link between altruism and grades in all seven years, and we could not find the book’s 11 percent figure in it. And five of the eight single studies whose samples we could confirm had fewer than 200 people in them. The call centre experiment had 39 callers.
Adam Grant Give and Take: The Argument in Brief
Grant is an organizational psychologist at Wharton. His own page for the book calls it a New York Times and Wall Street Journal bestseller translated into 30 languages. The argument is that success depends on how we deal with other people, on top of passion, hard work, talent and luck.
He has made the case outside the book too. In his TED talk, which showed more than 10.9 million plays on 15 November 2026, he says he surveyed more than 30,000 people across industries and cultures. A transcript of the talk has him finding the worst performers in engineering, medicine and sales were givers, and the best performers were givers again.
Search for Adam Grant Give and Take in the US and the first page is mostly summaries, retailers, reviews and Grant’s own pages and talks. A summary repeats the claim. We wanted the papers under it, the same reason we read 22 summaries of Rick Rubin’s The Creative Act against the book.
What Are Givers, Takers and Matchers?
Givers, takers and matchers are Grant’s three styles of dealing with other people at work. Takers try to get as much as they can from others. Matchers aim for an even trade, favour for favour. Givers contribute without expecting anything back. Grant says in his TED talk that most people are matchers.
Older business books cover the same ground from other angles. Stephen Covey’s fourth habit, think win-win, reads like a matcher’s rule stretched toward giving, and our 7 Habits of Highly Effective People summary sets out the habit itself. Robert Greene’s laws read like advice for the taker’s side of the table, and our 48 Laws of Power summary is worth reading beside this one. Dale Carnegie’s listening rules, covered in our How to Win Friends and Influence People summary, are what a giver sounds like in a conversation.

Who Ends Up at the Top and the Bottom?
Givers, at both ends. In the book’s first chapter, Grant reports that the least productive engineers, the lowest-scoring medical students and the weakest salespeople were givers, and so were the best performers in the same jobs. Takers and matchers land in the middle. Three studies carry that claim.
The details come from the published excerpt of chapter one. It describes more than 160 engineers in California, more than 600 medical students in Belgium, and salespeople in North Carolina. The excerpt’s own summary is that givers “dominate the bottom and the top of the success ladder.”
The engineers. The source is a 2003 paper by Francis Flynn in the Academy of Management Journal. Stanford’s page for it gives the sample as 161 employees of a large firm. The paper’s summary is more specific than the book’s. Being seen as generous went with higher status. Keeping favours in balance went with higher productivity. Exchanging favours often went with both.
The medical students. The source is a 2009 paper by Filip Lievens, Deniz Ones and Stephan Dilchert in the Journal of Applied Psychology. Its abstract gives the sample as 627 students in year one and 306 by year seven. The paper is about the Big Five personality traits, and its headline is conscientiousness. Altruism is one facet in one table.
That table, in the full paper, gives the link between altruism and grades as .09 in year one, close to zero in years two to four, and .27 in year seven. Every value is positive. The book’s excerpt says the students with the lowest grades had unusually high giver scores, and that being a giver accounted for 11 percent higher grades across medical school.
We could not find the 11 percent figure, or any negative link between altruism and grades, anywhere in the paper. Grant may have worked from data beyond the printed tables, and a correlation cannot show who clusters at the very bottom. What the paper does show is the second half of his story. Altruism counts for little in the early years and for more by year seven, and the authors tie rising validities to the growing share of clinical practice in the course.
The salespeople. The excerpt says the least productive salespeople had giver scores 25 percent above average, and the top performers were givers who brought in 50 percent more annual revenue than takers and matchers. The book’s reference list credits this to Grant and Dane Barnes, “Predicting Sales Revenue”, a working paper dated 2011. We searched for a published version on 14 and 15 November and found none, and the CV Grant posts on Wharton’s faculty site, dated May 2021, lists no paper with Barnes. The paper may still exist somewhere we did not look.
The 15 Studies Behind the Book
We chose 15 studies from the book’s reference list, which its Japanese publisher posts in full. The list runs to several hundred entries, so this is a sample, weighted toward the studies readers hear about most. Samples and findings are as stated on the page we link.
| Study | Authors and year | Where published | Sample on the page | What the paper reports |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Favour exchange among employees | Flynn, 2003 | Academy of Management Journal | 161 employees | Generosity went with status, balance with productivity, frequent exchange with both |
| Personality and medical school grades | Lievens, Ones and Dilchert, 2009 | Journal of Applied Psychology | 627 in year one, 306 in year seven | Altruism and grades: .09 in year one, .27 in year seven |
| Sales revenue and giver scores | Grant and Barnes, 2011 | Working paper | Not stated | No published version found |
| Fundraising callers who met a scholarship student | Grant and five co-authors, 2007 | Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes | 39 callers | 142% more phone time and 171% more money raised a month later |
| Narcissistic chief executives | Chatterjee and Hambrick, 2007 | Administrative Science Quarterly | 111 CEOs | Big wins and big losses; performance no better or worse overall |
| Cardiac surgeons at more than one hospital | Huckman and Pisano, 2006 | Management Science | Not stated | Results improved with volume at that hospital, not at others |
| Star analysts who change firms | Groysberg, Lee and Nanda, 2008 | Management Science | Not stated | Performance fell for at least five years, unless the team moved too |
| Couples estimating their share of household tasks | Ross and Sicoly, 1979 | Journal of Personality and Social Psychology | 37 couples | 27 of 37 couples claimed more than 100% between them |
| Volunteering and well-being | Windsor, Anstey and Rodgers, 2008 | The Gerontologist | 2,136 Australians aged 64 to 68 | Moderate volunteers did better than non-volunteers and heavy volunteers |
| Spending money on other people | Dunn, Aknin and Norton, 2008 | Science | 632 surveyed, 16 employees, 46 in the experiment | Spending on others predicted more happiness than spending on yourself |
| Cooperation spreading between strangers | Fowler and Christakis, 2010 | PNAS | Not stated | Generous play spread up to three degrees of separation |
| Women negotiating for themselves and for others | Amanatullah and Morris, 2010 | Journal of Personality and Social Psychology | 59 participants | $42,000 counteroffer for themselves, $49,107 for someone else |
| Social motives in negotiation | De Dreu, Weingart and Kwon, 2000 | Journal of Personality and Social Psychology | 28 studies | Prosocial negotiators reached better joint deals, if they also resisted yielding |
| Citizenship behaviour at work and results | Podsakoff and three co-authors, 2009 | Journal of Applied Psychology | 168 samples, 51,235 people | Going beyond the job went with better ratings for people and better results for units |
| Powerless speech and status | Fragale, 2006 | Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes | Not stated | Tentative speakers won more status where people depended on each other |
Ten of the 15 pages state a sample. Two of those are meta-analyses, which pool earlier research: 28 negotiation studies in one, and 168 samples covering 51,235 people in the other. That second one, on citizenship behaviour, the effort people give beyond their job descriptions, is the strongest evidence in the table that such effort pays, for the person and for the unit.
The other eight are single studies. Their main samples run from 39 callers to 2,136 Australians, and five of the eight sit under 200.
What Is Otherish Giving?
Otherish giving is Grant’s name for helping others while keeping your own interests in view. It explains the split between the givers at the top and the givers at the bottom. Selfless givers put other people’s interests ahead of their own. Otherish givers care about others too, keep their own interests in view, and set limits on when and whom they help.
In an interview with Knowledge at Wharton dated 10 April 2013, Grant said selfless givers are “at much greater risk of burnout and exploitation” than the otherish kind. If that risk sounds familiar, our guides to the stages of burnout and to how to stop being a people pleaser cover the practical side.
The idea has support in the table. The volunteering study found a curve. Australians in their mid-sixties who volunteered a moderate amount reported better well-being than those who did none and those who did a great deal. Giving had a ceiling, and past it the giver paid.
The negotiation meta-analysis says something similar in a different setting. Across 28 studies, negotiators who cared about the other side reached better joint outcomes, but only when they also resisted giving ground. Concern for others worked when it came with a spine.
A book built on Alfred Adler’s psychology draws the same boundary more bluntly. Its philosopher tells a young man to drop the need for approval, as our reading of The Courage to Be Disliked sets out. A selfless giver who cannot say no is often buying approval. An otherish giver is choosing where the help goes.

What the Smaller Studies Can and Cannot Carry
The call centre study is the one most people remember. Callers raising money for a university met a student whose scholarship their work had paid for. They talked for about five minutes. A month later those callers were spending 142 percent more time on the phone and raising 171 percent more money.
Experiment one had 39 callers, and 17 of them were in the group that met the student. It was a field experiment with control groups, and the effect was large. It was also 17 people in one call centre. Treat it as a reason to try the idea in your own team and measure what happens.
The overclaiming study is smaller still. Ross and Sicoly asked 37 married couples how much each did of 20 household activities, most of them chores. In 27 couples the two answers added up to more than the whole. People remember their own contributions better than anyone else’s. A manager can use that directly. Before you decide a colleague is a taker, list what they did.
The gender study had 59 participants negotiating a starting salary against a simulated hiring manager. Women bargaining for themselves countered at $42,000 on average. Women bargaining for a friend countered at $49,107, level with the men. The authors put the gap down to fear of backlash, with aspirations equal between women and men. Our guide on how to negotiate salary covers the mechanics of the counteroffer.
Then there are takers at the top. Chatterjee and Hambrick studied 111 chief executives in computer hardware and software between 1992 and 2004, scoring narcissism from signals such as how prominent the CEO’s photograph was in the annual report and their pay against the next executive. Grant told Knowledge at Wharton the typical taker CEO earned about seven times what the second-highest-paid executive did.
The paper’s conclusion is cooler than the anecdote. Narcissistic CEOs made bolder moves and produced bigger wins and bigger losses. Their firms did no better and no worse overall.
Tracing a famous claim to its page is a habit of ours. We did it with the Michael Phelps diet, with Mike Tyson’s everyone has a plan line, and with the Jennifer Aniston workout. Here the core idea holds, and the numbers people repeat are shakier than the idea.
How to Use the Book at Work
Start with Flynn’s finding: trade help often. The employees who exchanged favours frequently had both the status and the output. A giver who helps constantly and never asks is running a one-way account, and Flynn’s 161 employees point to asking more as the fix.
Asking is the part givers skip. If you would negotiate harder for a friend than for yourself, as the 59 participants in the salary study did, argue for your team, your family or your future hires when you ask. The request is the same and it is easier to say out loud.
Protect the work that only you can do. The surgeons in Huckman and Pisano’s study got better results at the hospital where they operated most, and the star analysts who changed firms slipped for at least five years unless their team came too. Performance lives in the people around you. That argues for helping them, and for learning how to delegate so the helping does not eat your own output.
Show people who their work helps. Five minutes with one scholarship student moved 17 callers. Most firms have a customer who could do the same for a product team.
Reputation is the giver’s long game, and it shows up in deals. Our pieces on how Ryan Reynolds built his net worth, on LeBron James net worth and on Mark Cuban net worth follow three fortunes through the deals and stakes behind them. Read them with one question: who wanted this person in the deal, and why.
Keep a ceiling. The volunteering curve bends down past a point, so decide how many hours a week go to other people’s problems.
How We Did This
On 14 November 2026 our newsroom read the reference list of Give and Take as posted by its Japanese publisher and chose 15 studies from it: the three behind the top-and-bottom claim and 12 that the book and Grant’s own talks and interviews return to most. For each we looked for the paper, its abstract or a university summary, and recorded the authors, year, journal, the sample as stated on that page and the finding in the paper’s own terms.
Where a page gave no sample we wrote “not stated” and did not fill it from memory. Journal pages that would not load, including PubMed, PNAS and SAGE, were replaced by repository or metadata copies of the same abstract. Google’s US results for Adam Grant Give and Take were read the same day and again on 15 November. The full dataset, with a supporting quote for every row, is available on request.
Frequently Asked Questions
Are most people givers, takers or matchers?
Matchers. Grant says in his TED talk that most of the more than 30,000 people he surveyed sit in the middle, trading favour for favour. He gives no percentage split in the talk, and we did not find one on the pages we read.
Do takers get ahead?
For a while. Grant’s line in the TED talk is that takers tend to rise quickly and fall quickly. The CEO study in his reference list is more measured: firms led by narcissistic chief executives swung harder in both directions and ended up no better or worse than the rest.
When was Give and Take published?
Kirkus Reviews gives the first release, by Viking, as 9 April 2013. Penguin Random House lists the Penguin Books paperback as published on 29 July 2014.
The strongest evidence in the book is also the least dramatic. Across 168 samples and 51,235 people, going beyond the job at work went with better results. The three studies behind the famous claim are thinner, and the advice that survives them is to trade help often and set a limit.

Written by
Editor of The Executive Insight. Writes about leadership, decision-making and the parts of building a business that nobody puts in the plan.
Explore other articles
-
business strategy
Most standard operating procedure examples you find online are documents nobody would ever read twice. Twelve pages, a version history, an approvals table, and a level of detail that guarantees it goes out of date within a month of being written. The test of an SOP is not whether it is thorough. It is whether […]
8 min read -
business strategy
Hiring your first employee is the point at which a self-employed person becomes an employer, and almost everyone gets the arithmetic wrong in the same direction. They budget the salary, confirm the revenue covers it, and make the offer. The salary is not the cost. It is somewhere between two thirds and three quarters of […]
7 min read -
business strategy
You run a company of 40 people, and someone has just sent you the Amazon leadership principles as the model for your culture. There are 16. Seven were already in Jeff Bezos’s 1997 shareholder letter, from the year Amazon’s staff grew to 614. Those are the ones built for your size, and four of them […]
18 min read









